Pin it
I've tried so many Christmas cookie recipes over the years, but these Holiday Everything Cookies have topped my list as the most beloved creation. There's something truly wonderful about the mix of sweet M&Ms, crunchy pretzels, and crisp potato chips that creates an unforgettable taste experience. When they're baking, my whole house fills with the most amazing buttery chocolate smell. My kids know the holidays have officially kicked off when this scent wafts through our home.
What Makes These Treats Outstanding
I've spent years tweaking this recipe in my home kitchen to get it just right. The combo of sweet meets salty creates something truly remarkable in every mouthful. Folks who try these tell me they can't go back to store-bought holiday treats anymore. I love how the M&Ms melt into little chocolate pools while the chips and pretzels add that satisfying crunch that keeps you coming back for more.
Your Shopping List
Let me walk you through the key ingredients that make these cookies so amazing. You'll want butter and eggs at room temp - this creates that wonderful chewy bite. Grab colorful M&Ms for holiday flair. I always break up the pretzels and chips by hand for the best texture. Good quality white chocolate really elevates the whole thing. These simple items come together to make something truly spectacular.
Easy Preparation Guide
Making these treats is all about getting each step right. Start by really whipping that butter and sugar until it's super fluffy - don't cut this short. Add eggs one by one for the best consistency. When you mix in flour, do it gently to keep your cookies soft. Then comes the best part - folding in all those tasty, crunchy bits.
Nailing It Every Batch
Getting your measurements right makes all the difference. I always lightly spoon flour into my cup instead of scooping. Making sure your ingredients aren't cold helps everything blend properly. Using a cookie scoop gives you even cooking times. These small tricks might seem picky, but they'll give you incredible results every single time.
Pin it
Prep Ahead Tips
You can freeze this dough no problem - I always keep some ready for unexpected holiday visitors. Just pop those frozen balls straight into the oven and add a minute or two to your baking time. I often make twice as much just to have extra on hand. It's like giving myself a tasty gift for later.
Crowd-Pleasing Favorites
These treats always spark joy at holiday get-togethers. The bright colors catch your eye right away, and that sweet-salty mix keeps everyone grabbing for seconds. I get such a kick out of watching people take their first bite and seeing their eyes light up. They're always the first empty spot on any cookie tray.
Keeping Them Fresh
If you somehow don't eat them all right away (which hardly ever happens at my place), these cookies stay great for days. Just pop them in a sealed container to keep that perfect texture. They'll stay tasty for several days, though they rarely stick around that long. The flavors actually get even better overnight - assuming you can wait that long!
Switch Things Up
What I love about this recipe is how flexible it is. Sometimes I throw in dark chocolate pieces instead, or add some butterscotch chips for extra richness. My followers are always sending me their own twists on the recipe - each version brings something new to enjoy.
Great Gifts
These treats make fantastic presents. I love putting them in holiday containers or clear bags with pretty ribbons. They look so festive, and that flavor combo always gets compliments. They work great for cookie swaps or sending care packages to friends and family.
Pin it
Custom Creations
While my standard version is thoroughly tested, feel free to play around with it. Some folks add various nuts for extra crunch, while others swap in their favorite candy types. The base dough works with so many additions. That's the fun of sharing recipes - seeing how everyone puts their own spin on things.
Holiday Custom
These cookies have become part of countless family celebrations over the years. They're so fun to make with children - kids love adding all the colorful mix-ins. The process is simple enough for beginners but impressive enough for baking pros. Each batch creates wonderful memories.
Spreading Cheer
Homemade treats really show you care during the holidays. I enjoy arranging these in cute packages for neighbors and friends. I always tuck the recipe inside - everyone asks for it anyway! These cookies just seem to bring happiness wherever they go.
Kitchen Bonding
These treats get the whole family involved in the kitchen. Kids can't wait to smash pretzels and sprinkle M&Ms. There's something special about making holiday goodies together. Even my screen-obsessed teens join in when we're making these!
Universal Appeal
Folks of all ages go crazy for these cookies. The balance of flavors and textures just works for everyone. They're fancy enough for grown-ups but fun enough for little ones. It's hard to find a treat that makes everyone happy, but this one does the trick.
Season's Wonder
These Everything Cookies have grown beyond just another treat in my holiday lineup. They're the first thing my family asks for, the item friends beg me to bring to gatherings. They represent everything wonderful about holiday baking - creating happiness through homemade goodies made with care in my kitchen.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the best way to measure flour?
- Spoon flour into your cup and level it off—don’t scoop! Weighing it (1 cup = 125g) works even better.
- → How do I get cookies to look perfectly round?
- Use a big circular cutter to shape warm cookies right after pulling them from the oven.
- → Can I toss more toppings in?
- Totally! Just press extra goodies onto the dough balls before they go in the oven for extra flair.
- → How long do these stay fresh?
- Keep them in a sealed container and they’ll stay good for around three days.
- → What if I want to try different mix-ins?
- Go ahead! Swap in your fave salty snacks or candy—just keep the ratio similar for best results.