Pin it
I first stumbled upon Philly Cheese Steaks wandering through downtown Philadelphia. That incredible sound of beef hitting the hot grill, the wonderful smell of cheese melting - it's absolutely wonderful! I've adjusted my recipe through the years, throwing in mushrooms for extra depth. Whenever I cook these up, I can't help but remember all the good times sharing these tasty sandwiches with my buddies.
What Makes This Special
The most basic foods often bring the most joy, and this sandwich definitely proves that point. If you're serving hungry sports fans or just want something totally comforting, you'll find this hits the spot. The juicy meat, stretchy cheese, and flavorful mushrooms work together beautifully.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Ribeye Steak: Go for quality meat - it makes all the difference
- Good Olive Oil: Just a splash to get everything cooking
- Sweet Onions: They'll turn golden and sweet
- Bell Peppers: For that authentic Philly taste
- Fresh Mushrooms: They grab all that wonderful beef flavor
- Fresh Garlic: Makes everything taste better
- Crusty Rolls: You'll want sturdy ones for all the fillings
- Provolone: Gets perfectly gooey when heated
Nutritional Benefits
While nobody would call this diet food, it's got some nutritional perks! The ribeye provides plenty of protein and iron, mushrooms add tons of nutrients, and those peppers bring vitamins to the party. I usually serve it with a fresh green salad on the side - helps me feel okay about eating another sandwich!
Cooking Instructions
- Cook Your Vegetables First:
- Heat your pan until it's really hot then throw in those veggies. Your onions and peppers need around 7 minutes to soften up nicely.
- Throw In The Mushrooms:
- Add mushrooms and garlic, cooking until everything looks golden and smells amazing.
- Cook The Beef:
- Move the veggies to one side and drop in that steak - it only needs a couple minutes to brown perfectly.
- Assemble Everything:
- Fill those rolls, top with cheese, and stick them under the broiler until everything melts together.
Pin it
Serving Suggestions
Let them cool for a moment - I know you can't wait! That initial bite with all that cheese pulling and juicy beef is totally worth the short wait.
Customization Ideas
Don't be afraid to switch things up! Try adding some hot peppers if you want spice, use a different cheese (just don't tell anyone from Philadelphia), or pile on extra mushrooms. It's your creation - customize it however you want.
Storing Extras
If you somehow don't finish everything (rare at my place!), they'll stay good in the fridge for a day or two. Just warm them carefully so your meat stays tender.
Great Side Dishes
These sandwiches go great with some crunchy fries or big onion rings. A cold beer works wonders too! When I want something lighter, I'll throw together a simple green salad.
Common Questions
You can totally use other beef cuts - just make sure they're sliced really thin. Don't like mushrooms? Just leave them out. While you can get stuff ready ahead of time, these taste way better when they're fresh off the stove.
Pin it
Perfect For Any Occasion
These sandwiches fit any situation - watching sports, family meals, or just because you want something awesome on a random weeknight. They always make everyone happy!
Bread Options
The standard hoagie roll works great, but feel free to try something different. Just pick bread that won't fall apart when loaded with all those juicy ingredients.
Modern Twist
Adding mushrooms might not follow strict tradition, but sometimes small changes create something even tastier. These fungi friends bring so much extra flavor to each bite.
All About The Mushrooms
Those mushrooms aren't just filler - they drink up all the fantastic steak juices and create this amazing depth of flavor. They also make each sandwich feel more substantial.
Success Factors
This sandwich gets everything right - juicy meat, melted cheese, perfectly cooked veggies, and that awesome mushroom addition. It's comfort food that somehow tastes even better than you'd expect from looking at the ingredients. Give it a shot - I'm sure it'll become your go-to sandwich!
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which meat works best?
Ribeye steak is your go-to for bold flavor and tenderness. Ask the butcher to slice it super thin or try freezing it a bit to slice yourself.
- → Can I switch the cheese?
Totally! Provolone is traditional, but American or cheddar are tasty too. Any cheese that melts nicely is a great pick.
- → What extras boost flavor?
A dash of hot sauce adds spice, jalapeños give heat, balsamic glaze adds sweetness, and Worcestershire sauce brings depth to the mix.
- → Are mushrooms necessary?
Nope! Skip them or swap for sautéed spinach if you'd like to try a different take.
- → What's the point of broiling?
It makes the cheese melt to bubbly perfection. Keep an eye on it so it doesn't burn!
Conclusion
Soft rolls are stuffed with juicy ribeye steak, sautéed mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers, then finished with melted provolone cheese for an irresistible sandwich.