Pin it
These Sticky Caramel Pecan Treats take me back to my nana's warm kitchen instantly. She'd whip up the most amazing pecan pies, and these cookies pack that same homey feel in every mouthful. The soft cookie bottom holds pools of gooey caramel while crunchy toasted pecans top it all off. My kitchen always smells heavenly with butter and caramel when I bake these. They've turned into the treat everyone begs for, particularly around holiday time. You'll see why they vanish so fast at parties after just one taste.
What Makes These Treats Extraordinary
The way pecan pie brings folks together has always made me smile, and these cookies work the same magic. They wrap up all the great stuff about southern pecan pie but in a handy cookie form. I first tried making these one lazy Sunday when I wanted pecan pie flavors without baking a whole pie. Now they show up at every family get-together and holiday bash we throw.
Good For Every Season
While these cookies rock at Christmas sales and Turkey Day feasts, I honestly bake them whenever the mood strikes. That sticky caramel middle with toasted pecans just works no matter what month it is. There's a touch of maple and cinnamon that gives them a warmth you can't say no to. My little ones love to help with the caramel drizzling, and I catch my hubby grabbing them right off the rack when they're cooling.
Your Shopping List
Here's what you'll grab to make these wonderful cookies. I always put everything on my counter first - it really helps the process go smoothly.
- For the Cookies: Soft butter, dark brown sugar for that caramelly taste, white sugar, a couple eggs, some vanilla cause it makes everything taste better, flour, baking soda, a pinch of salt, chopped pecans and a bit of cinnamon for that cozy feeling
- For The Yummy Topping: You need caramel sauce mixed with maple syrup plus some whole pecans to put on top
- Got Food Needs? Skip the nuts and try sunflower seeds or leave them out completely. Need no gluten? Any one-to-one flour mix works perfectly. Avoiding dairy? Try plant butter and double-check your caramel sauce ingredients
Let's Begin
I'll show you my tried-and-true way to make these mouthwatering cookies. After making them countless times, I've got some handy tricks to share with you.
Pin it
Getting Ready
Set your oven to 350°F. As it warms up, cover your cookie sheets with parchment paper. Don't skip the parchment paper, I promise it's worth it since that caramel gets super sticky and nobody wants to scrub pans later.
Creating Your Cookie Mixture
Here's where we start the good stuff. Mix your butter and sugars until they're light and fluffy for about 3 minutes. I usually take this chance to grab some coffee and enjoy the sweet buttery aroma filling up my kitchen. After that's done, put in your eggs one by one, then pour in a big splash of vanilla.
Working With Eggs
Don't rush the eggs part. I put them in one at a time and mix thoroughly between each. Your mixture should look smooth and creamy before adding the next egg. This little bit of care really changes how your cookies turn out.
Combining Dry Stuff
In another bowl, mix your flour, baking soda, salt and cinnamon together. Slowly add this to your wet mixture. I sometimes use a wooden spoon instead of my mixer here to avoid flour going everywhere and to keep from mixing too much. You want the dough to just come together.
Mixing In Nuts
Now comes my favorite bit, putting in those tasty chopped pecans. Fresh pecans taste so much better if you can find them. Just gently fold everything together to spread those crunchy bits all through your dough.
Pin it
Form And Cook
Scoop spoonfuls of dough onto your lined baking sheets. I use a tablespoon to make them all about the same size but don't worry too much about making perfect circles. Make sure to leave gaps between cookies since they'll spread while baking. Then they go in the oven for around 10-12 minutes. Get ready for your house to smell fantastic.
Preparing The Caramel Mix
While cookies are baking, gently heat your caramel sauce with maple syrup. Keep the heat low and stir carefully. This mix creates the best topping ever. I sometimes catch myself eating spoonfuls because it tastes so good.
Finishing Touches
After your cookies cool down, comes the fun part. Pour that warm caramel mixture over each cookie and place a pecan half on top. I love watching the caramel slowly flow into all the little cracks and dips.
My Cookie Secrets
Using ingredients that aren't cold makes such a big difference, especially the butter and eggs. Keep an eye on those cookies in the oven since they should still be a bit soft in the middle when you take them out. If your caramel gets too thick, just warm it up a little more. Sometimes I add a tiny bit of sea salt on top or throw in some mini chocolate chips when I'm feeling fancy. You can try so many different things with these.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make these cookies gluten-free?
You bet! Just swap out regular flour for your go-to gluten-free mix. They might turn out a bit different but will still taste great.
- → How should I store these cookies?
Keep them in a sealed container at room temp for up to 5 days. Put some wax paper between the layers so they won't stick together because of the caramel.
- → Can I freeze these cookies?
Sure thing, freeze the cookies after baking but before adding caramel. When you want to eat them, let them thaw completely and then add fresh caramel on top.
- → Why do ingredients need to be room temperature?
Stuff at room temp mixes way better and makes smoother dough. Your cookies will have nicer texture and bake more evenly this way.
- → Can I make these dairy-free?
For sure, grab some plant butter and non-dairy caramel sauce. Just double check that all your other stuff doesn't have dairy in it too.