Pin it
I whipped up something special in my kitchen - turning that juicy cheeseburger everyone loves into a hearty, spoonable treat. My blog followers kept asking for non-dairy options, so I crafted this Paleo soup that captures all those burger flavors without any milk products. My family couldn't tell the difference when they first tried it!
A Surprising Twist On Comfort Food
It's pretty awesome when you can switch up familiar tastes into something totally different. In just one pot, I've combined sizzling bacon, ground beef, and a clever cashew cheese mixture that'll remind you of biting into your neighborhood burger joint's best offering. What gets me is my kid now actually wants this soup instead of regular burgers!
Your Shopping List
- Bacon: Four strips from the good stuff. I grab mine downtown from Joe's Meats - it really counts.
- Ground Beef: One pound of quality meat. Try to get grass-fed for extra taste.
- Onion: Just one medium, chopped up small. The sweet kinds work great.
- Potatoes: Two medium ones, skin off and cut into chunks. They really fill you up.
- Tomatoes: A single can of the diced variety adds that burger sauce feel.
- Seasonings: Basic garlic powder and sea salt let everything else stand out.
- Cashews: They turn into the smoothest non-dairy cheese sauce you've tried.
- Nutritional Yeast: My go-to trick for cheese flavor without any dairy.
- Final Touches: Tomato paste, mustard and pickle juice make it taste just like the real deal.
First Steps
Get that bacon going until it's nice and crisp. I always use my grandma's old cast iron pan for this job. Your kitchen will start to smell incredible while those strips cook up. Save all that tasty bacon fat - we'll cook our meat in it for extra flavor power.
Meat Matters
Toss your beef into that same pan with all the bacon goodness. Crumble it with your wooden spoon and let it cook until there's no pink left. My little girl always tries to snag a few bits while I'm cooking because they smell so darn good. Put the beef aside but keep all those flavorful bits in your pan.
Veggie Time
Drop those chopped onions and potatoes straight into your pan. You'll see them get soft and clear as they soak up all that meaty flavor. This is when my kitchen starts to feel like we've got our own little roadside diner going.
Pin it
Soup Fundamentals
Now add your tomatoes, broth and spices. There's something wonderful about watching it all come together as it bubbles away. Your whole house will smell so good that don't be shocked if people from next door show up asking what's cooking.
The Cheesy Secret
Now for the fun part - making our dairy-free cheese sauce that'll fool anyone. Those soaked cashews turn super creamy when blended, especially with our special mix of nutritional yeast, pickle juice and mustard. It's my number one kitchen hack.
The Grand Finale
After the soup bubbles gently for about 15 minutes, stir in your cheese mixture and put that tasty beef back in. Everything swirls together into such a tempting soup. I often find myself just standing there breathing in the amazing smell. That's when my family starts hanging around asking when we can eat.
Dishing It Up
The best part comes next - getting it into bowls! I like putting out small dishes of toppings like those crunchy bacon pieces, shredded lettuce and chopped pickles. Everyone can fix their bowl exactly how they want their perfect burger. My guy always piles on extra bacon while the kids argue over who gets more pickles.
Tomorrow's Lunch
If you don't finish it all, this soup stays good in your fridge for a week. I usually make twice as much on weekends to enjoy all week long. The flavors actually get better after sitting for a day or two, just like any good homemade soup should.
Pin it
Smart Swaps
Need to cut carbs? I've made this tons of times using cauliflower or jicama instead of potatoes. They work great and still give you that nice chunky texture everyone wants. My keto-following sister can't get enough of this version.
Switch It Around
Some evenings I go with ground turkey or chicken instead. Last month I threw in some mushrooms and spinach and it was amazing. That's what cooking's all about - making things your own way. Folks who read my blog often send me pictures of how they changed things up.
Spice It Up
If you enjoy some heat, throw in some chopped jalapeños or a dash of hot sauce. My husband loves when I add chipotle peppers for that smoky kick. The best dishes are ones you can play around with.
Healthy Bonus
This soup isn't just tasty - it's pretty good for you too. It's loaded with protein from the meat, good fats from the cashews, and whatever veggies you decide to add. It's a whole meal in one bowl. Even my health-conscious friends ask for more.
Insider Tricks
For that cashew mix, you gotta be patient. I let my cashews soak overnight for the creamiest texture when blended. Sometimes I blend twice to get it super smooth. Don't be afraid to tweak the seasonings each time you cook it - trust what tastes good to you. Just yesterday I found out a bit more pickle juice made everyone's faces light up.
What I've Figured Out
After making this soup for years, I've learned to watch those potatoes like a hawk. You want them soft enough for a fork but not mushy. Another thing I've figured out is patience pays off. Let those flavors mix together while simmering - don't try to rush. You'll get the most amazing taste if you give it time.
Common Questions
Since posting this on my blog, I've gotten lots of great questions. Yes, you can definitely make it ahead for busy nights. Many of my readers prep it on weekends for quick meals during the week. If you can't do cashews, sunflower seeds work surprisingly well - I found this out when cooking for my nephew who can't have nuts. And freezing? This soup freezes perfectly - I often make extra to save for those nights when I just can't deal with cooking.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why do cashews need soaking?
Soaking softens them up, helping them blend smoother and creamier for the sauce.
- → Is the soup completely dairy-free?
Yes, it swaps dairy for cashews and nutritional yeast to give it a cheesy taste without any milk products.
- → What makes the soup fit Whole30 guidelines?
It’s made from only whole ingredients—no grains, dairy, legumes, or even additives.
- → Can the nutritional yeast be left out?
Sure, but the soup won’t have that cheesy flavor. It’ll still be rich and creamy!
- → Are other potatoes an option?
You can experiment, but Yukon gold potatoes work best as they keep their buttery taste and shape in soups.